Prajakta Koli, known to many as “MostlySane” on YouTube, makes her fiction debut with Too Good To Be True, a modern romance novel centered on love, self-worth, and the blurred lines between fiction and reality. The story follows Avani, a young woman who works at a bookstore and believes in dreamy, rom-com style love stories. When she meets a charming stranger named Aman, it feels like she’s living in one of those stories—until things get complicated.
Too Good To Be True Summary
Avani is your typical book lover—introverted, observant, and a hopeless romantic. She spends her days surrounded by stories in the bookstore where she works and often compares her real life to the fictional lives of the characters she reads about. One day, she meets Aman, a man who seems too perfect. He’s kind, good-looking, understanding, and says all the right things. Their connection feels instant and magical, almost like fate.
As their relationship develops, Avani finds herself falling fast and hard. But soon, she begins to notice things that don’t quite add up. Is Aman hiding something? Is this relationship as perfect as it seems, or is she just seeing what she wants to see?
Writing Style & Pacing
Prajakta’s writing is easy to follow and conversational—much like her online persona. She uses a simple, relatable tone that makes it easy for readers, especially young adults, to connect with the characters. The pacing is steady, though it leans more toward a slow-burn romance. Some scenes do feel a bit dragged out, and certain plot twists are predictable if you’re familiar with the genre.
There are moments when the story feels like it’s inspired more by a Netflix rom-com than real-life romance, but that also adds a fun, dreamy quality to it. The book doesn’t try to be overly deep or dramatic—it’s more about comfort, emotions, and relatable insecurities.
Read More: Godan by Munshi Premchand
Character Development
Avani is the heart of the story. She’s quirky, anxious, emotional, and often second-guesses herself—something many readers will relate to. Her love for books and the way she romanticizes life makes her a charming lead. Through her journey, she slowly learns to trust her instincts and gain confidence in who she is, rather than relying on someone else to complete her.
Aman, while dreamy and charming, is not explored as deeply. He feels a bit one-dimensional at times. We don’t get to understand much about his past or personality beyond what Avani sees. This may have been intentional, as it ties into the theme of “seeing only what we want to see in people,” but it still leaves the reader wanting more substance from him.
Themes & Message
The book’s core message is about understanding the difference between fantasy and reality when it comes to love. It reminds us that real relationships are built on more than just cute moments and sweet words. It also talks about how sometimes we ignore red flags because we’re too caught up in the idea of someone rather than who they truly are.
Another key theme is self-worth—learning to love yourself and realizing that you don’t need someone else to define your value. Avani’s journey from doubt to self-belief is subtle but meaningful.
Final Thoughts
Too Good To Be True is a light and enjoyable read that doesn’t try to be too complex or overly emotional. It’s meant to be comforting, sweet, and a little dreamy. While it doesn’t break new ground in the romance genre, it’s a solid first novel from Prajakta Koli, especially for fans of rom-coms and easy reads.
If you’re someone who enjoys simple love stories with a touch of self-discovery, or if you’re looking for a cozy weekend book to curl up with, this one might be worth your time.